Ritual humiliation for the masses…

I’ve never been a fan of X-factor, Pop Idol, Opportunity Knocks or any of the other cyclical talent shows that clog up peak-viewing hour on the goggle-box at weekends. I’m sure they have their place, but whatever or wherever this is, it ain’t in my place.

No one with half an ear would ever claim that these light entertainment shows have any great musical worth, being ground from the same karioki roots as ‘Stars In Their Eyes’ (albeit with less fun, less musicality and often less validity). They are blatant money making exercises – slap, snaffle and plop…a musical roulette wheel of fortune for this year’s sickly gaggle of puffed up impresarios.

The latest flavour of milli-vanilli autotunism was launched with much hype, claiming to be based upon a veneer of musical respectability. ‘The Voice’ claimed to be all about the music, not the image – a ‘credible’ alternative to the Callowed wishy-wash of wall-to-wall poppertune-ities. Auditions would be ‘blind’, with ‘mentors’ not judges, thereby ensuring that true talent would shine through the bluff of image and prettification.

Bullshit.

I’ve dipped in and out of the shows to date, in between trips to the loo to decorate the toilet with Technicolor yawns. Because from what I’ve seen, ‘The Voice’ is the most cynical affront to musicality of the bunch, if for no other reason that it takes itself seriously and pretends to be about more than $$$$.

The ‘mentors’ are qualified only insofar as they are recognisable to the viewer. Because let’s face it, those who know this industry would trust the talent-spotting instincts of a successful artist less than they would an office tea-boy. Look at all the artist-owned labels over the years, from Swansong (Led Zeppelin’s ill-fated dabble with labelism) to U2’s equally abortive effort. Recognising talent is an art in itself, best left to those with that rare skill rather than Joe Public on the one hand or Lady Wannagag-a, SmileyIrishEyes, Tom (‘I knew Elvis, Sinatra, Jesus’) or Dollar-Eyes-am on the other. At least Callow knows what’ll sell, and if he gets it wrong he has the muscle to manipulate the market.

From what I’ve seen, ‘The Voice’ betrays its pretentious claims from the outset. If any viewer believes that the last few standing will include more than one taken baldie/fattie/oldie/ugly, then they’re wallowing in Cloud Cuckoo land. The winner will be a twenty-something, photogenic, girl or boy next door type (with her or her signature already scratched into a contract in the producer’s lawyer’s safe). But what is so gut-wrenching is the competitive nature of the show, with contestants paired up in a boxing ring – a bloody boxing ring, for Christ’s sake – and metaphorically poked by the ‘mentors’ to outscream one another.

I’ve rarely, if ever, seen anything quite so tasteless since watching Hughie Green leer at Lena Zaveroni’s twelve-year-old cleavage.

Any self-respecting musician should be ashamed to participate in this sordid travesty of an entertainment show. In its own way, I find it as disgusting as the Black And White Minstrels show, which also justified its existence on the basis of mega viewing figures.

We’ll look back on this string of shoddy karioki competitions with embarrassment, recognising that they did more to damage the standing of pop and rock music than digital file-sharing or Eurovision.

Ten years ago, when Pop Idol sued X-factor and vice versa, Universal GAVE Battery Studios to the A+R man behind Pop Idol in settlement of a law suit bought for signing the winning act in contravention to the contractual conditions participants had agreed when entering the competition. Universal had acquired Battery within the context of their (forced) purchase of Zomba. They tossed it at an irritating litigant to resolve a talent show headache and he immediately flogged the studio to a property developer to cash in his ill-gotten gains, thereby proving that the major record company and the television talent-show mogul were at one in utterly disregarding (if not despising) the mechanics of true music.

A plague on all your houses.

On the other hand…

Huge congratulations to Kate Bush for winning this year’s South Bank Pop Awards in addition to nominations for just about every other award going. She has yet again proved an inspiration to aspiring artists determined to retain their individuality and identity despite the massive pressures to conform to the lowest common denominator applied by wall-to-wall television karioki shows.

It can be done, although it requires a determination and belief (not to mention a degree of talent) that is rare indeed.

  1. Producer Michael Johnson talks with Russell Cottier
  2. The March RP Newsletter
  3. Favourite Producer Photos of 2011
  4. Bye Bye CD – I was never keen on you anyway
  5. Ken Scott talks about Epic Drums at Abbey Rd – Pt 3
  6. Stuart Bruce video interview with George Shilling
  7. Ken Scott interview at Abbey Road Studios – Part 2
  8. Ken Scott interview at Abbey Road Studios – Part 1
  9. Air Studios Guitar Recording Masterclass
  10. Eccentric: Tyrannosaurus Rex
  11. Students shown how to dismantle an atomic bomb
  12. Eccentric: For the love of money….?
  13. Jake Jackson Video Interview at Air Studios
  14. Fran Ashcroft – Going All Eleanor Rigby
  15. Danton Supple – New Video Interview
  16. Yoad Nevo Video Interview
  17. Dimitri Tikovoi – Music Producer Video Feature
  18. Small new Welsh studio video tour: Opec Studios
  19. The Full English Podcast – v3.0 Bacon with extra sizzle – Blake talks to Phil about Studio Assistants
  20. Russell Cottier’s Video Blog – Number Two
  21. The Full English Podcasts by Phil English
  22. Basic Drum Recording – Using Just One Mic
  23. Fran Ashcroft: Dear Editor
  24. Top NYC Multi-Room Studio Hits 4 Grammys with Dangerous Music Gear
  25. Russell Cottier’s Video Blog :: Impedance & Guitar Recording
  26. Phill Brown Video Interview – Legendary Record Producer
  27. Studio photos of the week: Sphere Studios
  28. Fran Ashcroft: How do Magnets Work?
  29. Video feature with Dominik Johnson – Multi-instrumentalist & producer
  30. Art of Recording Vocals
  31. SSL release Duende Native Plug-In Collection
  32. MUSIC PRODUCERS GUILD AWARDS 2011 – THE WINNERS
  33. Chairworks Studios adds Prism Sound ADA-8XR Converters
  34. Fran Ashcroft: Tosspot Digital Recording
  35. Fran Ashcroft: Is it a Washing Machine? No, that’s my Bass
  36. PWL – From The Factory Floor – Behind the scenes book by Phil Harding
  37. Fran Ashcroft: Doing an HMV
  38. Music Producers Guild (UK) Awards 2011 Returns To Café De Paris
  39. Ann Mincieli – Recording Engineer Video at Germano Studios, NY
  40. Forward Studios opens “World-Class Mastering Studio”
  41. Fran Ashcroft – And the Winner is….
  42. Latch Lake micKing – Microphone Stand with Attitude
  43. Beatles Zebra saved by Government
  44. James Towler – Recording Drums Live
  45. Tony Visconti – The lost Video Interviews
  46. Fran Ashcroft – On the latest incarnation of MySpace
  47. Experienced and fancy a job in a new EU studio?
  48. The Art of Audio Recording – Video tutorials
  49. Fran Ashcroft – Generals and Majors
  50. Andy Sneap talks with George Shilling – Record producer video feature
  51. HD high noon Converter shoot-out at Metropolis Studios
  52. SNAP! Recording Studios – Video Tour
  53. David Pye – Recording Engineer Video Feature
  54. Kore Studios – New Video Feature
  55. APRS to Honour Industry Greats at Annual APRS Sound Fellowship Presentation
  56. Neumann launches high end Studio Monitor series
  57. Fran Ashcroft: The Pain and Suffering Index
  58. Fran Ashcroft – Ashes to Ashes
  59. William Orbit – Free producer event at the London O2
  60. Fran Ashcroft: Why You Should Keep Mice Out Of Your Studio
  61. Musicians in the Studio – Photo Gallery
  62. Fran Ashcroft: Kiss Your Career Goodbye
  63. George Shilling’s Masterclass: Real-World Mixing in Pro Tools 8 HD
  64. SSL expands XLogic X-Rack with Stereo EQ
  65. Fran Ashcroft: Am I being Realistic?
  66. Record Producer Video of the Week: Tony Platt
  67. Producer photo of the week: Paul Epworth
  68. Confessions of A Studio Owner, Pt 28: The Compressor’s Useless Facts
  69. Fran Ashcroft: The No Future Jobs Scheme
  70. Confessions of a Studio Owner 27: Kitchen Pickers Bigger Knickers
  71. Record Producer Photo/Video of the Week: Toby Smith
  72. Fran Ashcroft: Call me Bill, it sounds more expensive
  73. Part 26 of the Confessions of a Studio Owner: Buy British….
  74. Producer Andy Ross feature at Astar Studios, Lancashire, UK
  75. Steffan Thomas, owner of Octagon Studios, Port Talbot feature
  76. Ed Tutton – Producer Video Feature
  77. Studio Photo of the Week: Nutshed Studios, Ireland
  78. Confessions of a Studio Owner: The compressor Turns 25! Time for some Charity!
  79. Dean Street Studios – New video feature
  80. Metal Producer Andy Sneap talks production with Russ Russell
  81. Confessions of a Studio owner, The Compressor Part 24, Stand Up
  82. Remastered archive producer video of the week: Greg Penny
  83. Confessions of a Studio Owner Part 23: Waiting for Bono.
  84. Producer Photo of the week: Chris Porter
  85. Fran Ashcroft: Answers on a Postcard, Please….
  86. The Compressor – Part C22 of his amazing saga – Fate
  87. Record Producer Photo of the Week – Russ Russell
  88. The Tony Faulkner Video Interview
  89. Producer Video Feature – Kipper
  90. Confessions of a Studio Owner – Pt 21
  91. AES London – Much better than expected shock
  92. Confessions of a Studio Owner: Pt 20, The Compressor Cleans Up
  93. Confessions of A Studio Owner: The Compressor’s Manifesto!
  94. Producer photo of the week
  95. New Producer Features This Week: Guy Massey and Mike Crossey
  96. The Compressor – Confessions of a Studio Owner – Part 18
  97. James Towler – New recording techniques video
  98. Producer Photo and Video of The Week – Andy Gill
  99. Bernard Butler Video Interview at Edwyn Collins Studio
  100. The Compressor – Confessions of a Studio Owner
  101. Video tour around McNally Smith Studio facility
  102. Hookend Manor Studios – Possibly the funkiest studio video we’ve done so far
  103. Photo of the Week – Robert Orton
  104. James Towler – Drum recording video
  105. Phil Harding Video Interview Series – Parts 1 to 4
  106. The Compressor is on a Mission From God
  107. NEW Yellow Shark Studios Video
  108. Photo of the week – Ann Miniceli
  109. Russell Cottier producer video with Fran Ashcroft
  110. The Compressor…..The Yakuza…The Mistress….The Wine….The advance.
  111. OK Go – This Too Shall Pass – RGM version
  112. Confessions of a Studio Owner – The Compressor is Big Brother
  113. THE COMPRESSOR SEES THE LIGHT…. HALLELUJAH
  114. Compressor Week: The Compressor gets Philosophical
  115. Photo of the Week – Real World Studios
  116. York Street Studios, New Zealand. Video feature
  117. Doug Trantow – Producer interview at LA Sound Gallery
  118. Mike Bennett – Music Producer Video – Part 1
  119. Photo of the Week – Paul Epworth
  120. The Compressor Rips up the Rule Book
  121. Phil Harding Producer/Engineer Video Interview – Part Two
  122. Dean Street Studios launch new SSL Duality Room
  123. Phil Harding talks about PWL and more. Part One
  124. The Compressor wakes up in a cold sweat
  125. Drum Recording Masterclass Video with Sean Genockey
  126. Photo of the week
  127. The Compressor looks for a reason to smile
  128. Drum Recording Masterclass VIDEO with George Shilling
  129. The Compressor : Educashion…..because the kidz iz our future…innit?
  130. Turn the Internet OFF and save the Music
  131. Reasons to be cheerful about audio in 2010
  132. Clint Murphy’s drum recording techniques – Pt 2
  133. Drum Recording Workshop
  134. The Compressor : What do Producers do?
  135. Why does the digital radio sound worse? (In the UK)
  136. Fantastic Studio Tour / Feature on Modern World Studio’s Site
  137. John Leckie video interview with George Shilling
  138. Vocal Comping – Video by Ken Lewis
  139. Prime Studios, Austria. Outboard gear video
  140. Confessions of a Studio Owner – The Compressor Way
  141. 10 Years of RecordProduction.com
  142. Getting ahead in the music industry – by fair means of foul
  143. Ken Lewis vocal comping
  144. Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year…..HUMBUG
  145. George Martin photo of the week
  146. James Towler nominated for 2 Grammy awards & MPG award
  147. The Old Abbey Road Canteen and Toilet Paper
  148. Mike Bennett talks about recording Lo Fi
  149. Autotune madness – Scientists take a look
  150. George Martin awards Trevor Horn, Peter Gabriel….. APRS
  151. Part 2 of Compressor’s “What does the future hold for studios?”
  152. Phil Harding launches book – PWL from the Factory Floor
  153. Future Loops Announces “Stewart Walker Minimal Sessions”
  154. Pt 3 of 3 – Recording Electric Guitars with Miggs & Ken Lewis
  155. UMPG Publisher of the Year, Song of the Year – ASCAP Awards
  156. Gustavo Celis nominated for a Latin Grammy Award
  157. London, UK. Cream Studios under new management
  158. What does the future hold for studios? Part 1 – Compressor
  159. Spotify, i-Tunes and the X-Frigging-Factor – Fran Ashcroft
  160. Bill of rights – Compressor
  161. Pt 2 of 3, Recording Electric Guitars w/ Miggs & Ken Lewis
  162. ‘Secret Confessions of a Studio Owner!’ – Compressor
  163. Part One – Recording Electric guitars w/ Miggs & Ken Lewis
  164. Last chance to nominate for the UK’s MPG awards
  165. 25th TEC Awards – Mixing Console prize goes to….
  166. Dave Eringa – World Authority on Spuds